LawsPublished Top storyAll news from that day
Judge dismisses Penske Media’s antitrust suit over Google AI Overviews
Judge Amit Mehta of the US District Court for the District of Columbia granted Google’s motion to dismiss Penske Media’s amended complaint in an opinion dated 30 September 2026.
Check our sources · 6 facts from 1 source
AgnosticPreachersKid / E. Barrett Prettyman Federal Courthouse, DC / Public domain, cropped
Key points
- The court granted Google’s motion to dismiss the Penske Media plaintiffs’ amended complaint, in a memorandum opinion dated 30 September 2026 that also covers Chegg v. Google.
- The plaintiffs alleged Google used its search monopoly to coerce publishers into supplying content it republishes, and that it unlawfully ties AI Overviews to its general search product.
- The court declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the unjust enrichment claims and dismissed them. The opinion says a final, appealable order accompanies it.
What happened
Judge Amit P. Mehta of the US District Court for the District of Columbia dated a memorandum opinion 30 September 2026 covering Chegg v. Google and Penske Media Corporation v. Google.
The court granted Google’s motion to dismiss the Penske Media plaintiffs’ amended complaint.
The plaintiffs alleged Google leveraged monopoly power in general search to coerce publishers to supply content that Google republishes to compete with them.
The Penske Media plaintiffs also brought an unlawful tying claim, alleging that Google unlawfully ties AI Overviews to its general search product.
The court declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the unjust enrichment claims and dismissed them.
The opinion says a final, appealable order accompanies it.
Underlined sentences link to the facts we checked. Dotted words open a short explainer.
Fact 2 of 6 · from US District Court for the District of Columbia, 30 Sep 2026
Defendants' Motion to Dismiss the PMC Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint is also granted. PMC Docket, ECF No. 25.
Fact 3 of 6 · from US District Court for the District of Columbia, 30 Sep 2026
Plaintiffs assert that Google has leveraged monopoly power in the general search services market to coerce them and other online publishers to supply cost-free content to Google. Google then republishes that content to its users to compete with those same publishers
Fact 4 of 6 · from US District Court for the District of Columbia, 30 Sep 2026
Finally, only the PMC Plaintiffs assert an unlawful tying claim in Count V of their Amended Complaint. ... They maintain that Google unlawfully ties AI Overviews to its general search product in violation of Section 2.
Fact 5 of 6 · from US District Court for the District of Columbia, 30 Sep 2026
the court declines to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over Plaintiffs' unjust enrichment claims. Accordingly, the court will dismiss Chegg's Count VI and the PMC Plaintiffs' Count VII.
Fact 6 of 6 · from US District Court for the District of Columbia, 30 Sep 2026
A final, appealable order accompanies this Memorandum Opinion.
What it means for you
Our viewThis is a ruling on Google’s motion to dismiss, and the opinion says an appealable order accompanies it, so Penske Media can still appeal. The claims we have checked do not set out how the court treated the tying allegation, so read the opinion itself before drawing conclusions about AI Overviews.
If you license content to AI search products, or plan to, ask your counsel to read the opinion’s treatment of the coercion and tying allegations, and watch for any notice of appeal.
It adds no new facts.
Your reaction
We count reactions per story and day, never who reacted. The counts help us choose what goes in the monthly issue. If you are signed in, your own page shows yours too.
We count reactions per story and day, never who reacted. They help choose what goes in the monthly issue.
Check our sources
Every sentence above is checked against this source.
1 Memorandum Opinion, Chegg v. Google and Penske Media v. Google (D.D.C.)
Open the source archived copy-
Judge Amit P. Mehta of the US District Court for the District of Columbia dated a memorandum opinion 30 September 2026 covering Chegg v. Google and Penske Media Corporation v. Google.
citeCHEGG, INC., Plaintiffs, v. GOOGLE LLC, et al. ... PENSKE MEDIA CORPORATION, et al., Plaintiffs, v. GOOGLE LLC, et al. ... MEMORANDUM OPINION ... Dated: September 30, 2026 Amit P. Mehta United States District Judge
-
The court granted Google’s motion to dismiss the Penske Media plaintiffs’ amended complaint.
citeDefendants' Motion to Dismiss the PMC Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint is also granted. PMC Docket, ECF No. 25.
-
The plaintiffs alleged Google leveraged monopoly power in general search to coerce publishers to supply content that Google republishes to compete with them.
citePlaintiffs assert that Google has leveraged monopoly power in the general search services market to coerce them and other online publishers to supply cost-free content to Google. Google then republishes that content to its users to compete with those same publishers
-
The Penske Media plaintiffs also brought an unlawful tying claim, alleging that Google unlawfully ties AI Overviews to its general search product.
citeFinally, only the PMC Plaintiffs assert an unlawful tying claim in Count V of their Amended Complaint. ... They maintain that Google unlawfully ties AI Overviews to its general search product in violation of Section 2.
-
The court declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the unjust enrichment claims and dismissed them.
citethe court declines to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over Plaintiffs' unjust enrichment claims. Accordingly, the court will dismiss Chegg's Count VI and the PMC Plaintiffs' Count VII.
-
The opinion says a final, appealable order accompanies it.
citeA final, appealable order accompanies this Memorandum Opinion.
Every sentence above is checked against this source. Each fact has its own address you can cite.
Source 1 · US District Court for the District of Columbia · 30 Sep 2026
Memorandum Opinion, Chegg v. Google and Penske Media v. Google (D.D.C.)
Judge Amit P. Mehta of the US District Court for the District of Columbia dated a memorandum opinion 30 September 2026 covering Chegg v. Google and Penske Media Corporation v. Google.
CHEGG, INC., Plaintiffs, v. GOOGLE LLC, et al. ... PENSKE MEDIA CORPORATION, et al., Plaintiffs, v. GOOGLE LLC, et al. ... MEMORANDUM OPINION ... Dated: September 30, 2026 Amit P. Mehta United States District Judge
The court granted Google’s motion to dismiss the Penske Media plaintiffs’ amended complaint.
Defendants' Motion to Dismiss the PMC Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint is also granted. PMC Docket, ECF No. 25.
The plaintiffs alleged Google leveraged monopoly power in general search to coerce publishers to supply content that Google republishes to compete with them.
Plaintiffs assert that Google has leveraged monopoly power in the general search services market to coerce them and other online publishers to supply cost-free content to Google. Google then republishes that content to its users to compete with those same publishers
Show all 6 factsShow fewer facts
The Penske Media plaintiffs also brought an unlawful tying claim, alleging that Google unlawfully ties AI Overviews to its general search product.
Finally, only the PMC Plaintiffs assert an unlawful tying claim in Count V of their Amended Complaint. ... They maintain that Google unlawfully ties AI Overviews to its general search product in violation of Section 2.
The court declined to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the unjust enrichment claims and dismissed them.
the court declines to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over Plaintiffs' unjust enrichment claims. Accordingly, the court will dismiss Chegg's Count VI and the PMC Plaintiffs' Count VII.
The opinion says a final, appealable order accompanies it.
A final, appealable order accompanies this Memorandum Opinion.
Topics
The morning email
On the mornings we publish: the three top stories and up to four short ones. Free.
We email you a link to confirm. An issue may include one sponsor, always labelled Sponsored · Advertisement. Our emails count opens and clicks, not who made them. Unsubscribe in one click. What we keep